Should I Use an Auto Broker or Car Buying Concierge?

auto broker

There is big difference between a traditional auto broker and independent car buying concierge services, like YCBA, for example.

An auto broker may purchase a vehicle for you, then mark up the vehicle.

They might even buy the vehicle at auction. Car buying brokers can locate a vehicle and help negotiate a purchase, but they will often purchase your trade in and sell it for profit.

Sometimes an auto broker will work with specific dealerships who pay them a commission. The car broker will work with the dealership who offers the best commission.

They typically will negotiate the sale price but not the finance options for the buyer.

When an auto broker is being paid on both ends of the deal, by the dealership AND the consumer, this of course creates a conflict of interest.

Car brokers are unable to work in a fiduciary capacity for the consumer when paid by both sides.

Most car buying concierge services are different from auto brokers

Your Car Buying Advocate – founded by Mike Rumple, a former car salesman, who was sick of the conflict of interest. He set out to provide a consumer advocate experience like no other.

Car Buying Services like YCBA alleviate the conflict of interest because no compensation is accepted from anyone other than the consumer.

This allows a true advocate for the car buying consumer. That’s a big difference from an auto broker.

In fact, you can find YCBA listed as a number one car buying service in 2021 on

Working in a fiduciary capacity allows us to never waiver on our principles of loyalty, trust and obligation to serve our clients with all of the information they need to make an informed car buying decision.

The Truth About Your Car Buying Advocate, Inc.

  • We never get paid based off the price of the vehicle.
  • We never take commissions from dealerships. 
  • We always negotiate all aspects of the deal including sale price, interest rates, warranties and add ons. 
  • We never purchase a vehicle and resell for profit like an auto broker
  • We negotiate your trade in or help you market your car personal owner to get you the most bang for your buck. 
  • We truly only have your best interest in mind. 
  • We accept compensation outside of the car deal, which allows us to freely advocate on your behalf. 
  • We work for you! 

The Reason We Are Car Consumer Advocates.

There is a very specific reason we call ourselves advocates.
We speak on behalf of and represent our clients. We bring comfort to the car buying process. With our knowledge of the car buying process and auto industry we negotiate FOR the client.

This is an exploding concept in the auto industry and has been a long time coming need. Consumers need experts to help them make informed car buying decisions. We provide the security and safety that is rarely present during car deals. We solely work and advocate for consumers which is revolutionizing the car buying experience. Auto brokers may be helpful in some scenarios, but if you need an advocate, you’ll want to find a trusted car buying concierge service.

To help more and more consumers, we are creating a network of car buying experts that can work independently and on behalf of the consumer. If you’re looking for an expert to help you in your car buying process or you’re an expert looking to help a consumer, slip us a note here so we can connect.

This Post Has 3 Comments

  1. Hannah Head

    Hi: It is Veteran Day so you may not be available. I have down loaded your free E book so should I read that 1st and then try to buy or talk with you first. I am really feeling doubtful about everything at this point because I have been researching so long. finally the interests rates are where I want them, however the car I want is still expensive.

Leave a Reply

five − 3 =

Want Car Buying Secrets and Tips?

Become an expert car buyer

read Next

car buying mistakes

5 Car Buying Mistakes

Let’s talk about the 5 Car Buying Mistakes people make.
It’s a complicated transaction; buying a car.
You have got to come in with the knowledge and confidence to make yourself a fair and even better good deal.

Read More »